Does Sugar Cause Inflammation? (And What About Fruit and Honey?)

I’ve never been much of a soda drinker. Growing up, we drank mostly water, plus an orange soda with my dad on the occasional summer day. My mom drank Diet Coke, but I never liked the taste, and it hurt my throat to swallow.

These days, I have a mini (7.5 oz) Dr Pepper every month or two, usually during a migraine. After trying lots of other things, I noticed that the quick sugar/caffeine combination often helps my migraines when all other methods haven’t been successful. 

That sent me researching whether to choose regular or diet soda. I chose regular because of what I read about artificial sweeteners and gut health. That’s my experience, and everyone is different. But it got me asking the bigger question: does sugar cause inflammation, and to what extent?

Below is the short answer, then what the research shows, which sugars matter most, and how much is okay.

The short answer: Too much added sugar can raise inflammation a little, and sugary drinks are the biggest concern. They’re the biggest source of added sugar in the American diet, about a quarter, and over years they’re linked with weight gain, type 2 diabetes, metabolic syndrome, and heart disease. Whole fruit is different: in feeding studies, fruit lowered inflammation markers. You don’t have to cut sugar to zero, though. Staying under about six teaspoons of added sugar a day matters more.

What the Research Says About Sugar and Inflammation

Here’s how the research on sugar and inflammation stacks up, strongest evidence first.

CRP (C-reactive protein) is a protein your liver makes when there’s inflammation in your body, and it’s the marker most of these studies measured. For heart health, under 1 mg/L is considered low, 1 to 3 is average, and over 3 is high.

What the research foundType of researchHow sure?
Fruit lowered CRP (by 0.5 mg/L)Feeding trials; 83 studies of fruit and vegetablesModerate
Women eating the most fast-digesting carbs, mainly starchy foods that break down into sugar quickly, like cold cereal, white bread, and white rice, had higher CRP (3.8 vs 1.4 mg/L), especially with a BMI of 25 or more (5.0 vs 1.6).Observational, 244 middle-aged womenModerate. A much larger study of 18,137 women found a smaller difference (0.2 mg/L)
In short trials, most sugar sources, including sugary drinks on their own, didn’t change CRP. Trials mixing sugary drinks with other sweet foods raised it a little (0.6 mg/L).64 feeding trials, about 4,000 peopleModerate to low
Fructose, a sugar found in fruit, honey, and table sugar, isn’t worse than other sugars for inflammation13 trials pooledLow

The link between fast-digesting carbs and inflammation was stronger in women carrying extra weight. That matters in midlife, when insulin resistance becomes more common.

Keep in mind that the lead author of the 64-trial review in the third row was partly funded by the Canadian Sugar Institute, a sugar industry group.

Most of these studies lasted only a few weeks, and CRP is just one blood marker. You may have read that one soda a day raised inflammation in three weeks, but in that small study, CRP also rose when the men weren’t drinking the study sodas.

The bigger picture comes from studies that followed people for years: drinking sugary drinks regularly is linked with weight gain, type 2 diabetes, metabolic syndrome, and heart disease, and inflammation is part of all of them. So the concern is a daily sugar habit over years, not one dessert or a little sugar here and there.

Why Does Sugar Cause Inflammation?

Researchers point to a few ways sugar could increase inflammation. Most work indirectly, and some are better supported than others.

How it happensWhat the research showsHow sure?
Extra weight, especially around the middleIn a six-month trial, overweight adults who drank about a liter of regular cola a day (about three cans) gained more belly fat than those who drank milk, diet cola, or water. Across 51 studies, more body fat was linked to higher CRP, especially in women, and weight loss lowered it.Moderate. One small trial (47 people), plus large reviews
Liver fatIn the same trial, liver fat more than doubled with regular cola. Adults around age 63 who drank sugary drinks once a week or more had 2.5 times the odds of developing fatty liver over six years.Moderate. One small trial, plus observational
Uric acidSugary soda and orange juice are linked with gout, a type of joint inflammation, in women.Moderate, observational
Blood sugar spikesVery high blood sugar, held for hours by IV, raised inflammation markers within two hours.Low for everyday eating. In a review of 28 trials, low glycemic diets didn’t change CRP.

For more on fatty liver, see my fatty liver diet guide. I explain the blood sugar study in Is Oatmeal Anti-Inflammatory?, and you can see what happened to my own blood sugar in my continuous glucose monitor experiment.

Does All Sugar Count? Fruit, Honey, and Maple Syrup

The source of the sugar also matters!

Sugar sourceWhat the research shows
Whole fruitLowered CRP (by 0.5 mg/L) and TNF-alpha in feeding trials. Fruit and vegetables lowered both across 83 studies
Dark chocolateLowered IL-6, another inflammation marker, in short trials
100% fruit juiceLowered CRP when it replaced other foods in two small trials, but one glass or more a day is linked with gout in women
HoneyActed the same as table sugar and corn syrup
Maple syrup, agave, coconut sugarNo studies in people on inflammation. Count them as added sugar.
Sugary drinks (soda, sweet tea, energy drinks)Didn’t change CRP on their own in short trials. Over years, they’re linked with weight gain, fatty liver, and type 2 diabetes.

The sugar in fruit is packaged with fiber, water, and plant compounds, so it acts differently in your body. You don’t need to limit whole fruit to lower inflammation. It’s on the anti-inflammatory side of my printable food lists for a reason, and berries made my list of the top 10 anti-inflammatory foods to eat every week.

Juice is different. For juice, my rule of thumb is about 4 ounces or less of 100% juice at a time, which I explain in my anti-inflammatory drinks article.

Honey and maple syrup feel more natural, but they still count as added sugar. In a study where adults ate 50 g a day of honey, table sugar, or corn syrup for two weeks each, all three raised triglycerides the same way. In people with impaired glucose tolerance, a type of prediabetes, all three raised CRP. If you prefer honey or maple syrup, use limited amounts to stay within the recommended daily added sugar.

Does Sugar Cause Inflammation in Your Joints?

The research here is about soda more than sugar in general.

  • Rheumatoid arthritis. In two large studies of almost 187,000 women, those who drank one or more regular sodas a day had a 63% higher rate of developing rheumatoid arthritis (the seropositive type), compared with women who rarely or never drank soda. The link was stronger for RA that started after age 55. Diet soda wasn’t linked. RA is uncommon, so a higher rate still means a small number of women.
  • RA flares. When 217 people with RA were asked which foods made their symptoms worse, regular soda and desserts topped the list. Blueberries and spinach topped the “better” list. That’s what people reported, not a measured change.
  • Gout. Gout is joint inflammation caused by uric acid crystals. Women who drank one regular soda a day had a 74% higher risk, and orange juice showed a similar link. Gout is rare in women, so the extra cases were small: about 36 more per 100,000 women each year for a daily soda.

If you have arthritis, I cover the foods with the strongest evidence in my rheumatoid arthritis diet guide.

Sugar, Your Gut, and Your Immune System

Does Sugar Hurt Your Gut?

This was the question behind my own regular-or-diet Dr Pepper decision.

In one small study, a liter of water sweetened with 110 g of sugar (about three cans of soda’s worth) raised bacterial toxin from the gut in the blood by about 45% two hours later. The same sweetness from sucralose didn’t, and neither did a starch drink with the same calories.

People who eat more added sugar and drink more soda also have higher rates of Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis, but most of those studies asked people to remember what they ate years earlier. Studies of sugar and gut bacteria in people are mixed so far, and the dose and whether the sugar is in a drink or a food seem to matter.

Does Sugar Weaken Your Immune System?

You may have seen the claim that sugar weakens your white blood cells for hours. It traces back to a small 1973 lab study. It measured how white blood cells behaved in a test, not whether anyone got sick, and it hasn’t been properly repeated in healthy people.

What matters more is your blood sugar over time. In a study of more than 85,000 people with diabetes, the risk of infection rose as A1c went up. On the other hand, carbs during long workouts didn’t weaken immune cells in trained athletes.

What About Diet Soda and Artificial Sweeteners?

Only a few small studies in people have measured inflammation with artificial sweeteners. In one, healthy adults who took sucralose daily for 30 days had higher inflammation markers and about 20% lower insulin sensitivity. In another, stevia added to a fruit drink for 60 days raised an anti-inflammatory marker.

Sweeteners can also change your gut bacteria. In a two-week study of 120 adults, saccharin (Sweet’N Low), sucralose (Splenda), aspartame (Equal, NutraSweet), and stevia (Truvia, Stevia in the Raw) each changed gut and mouth bacteria. Saccharin and sucralose also raised blood sugar responses in some people, and effects varied widely from person to person. Two longer stevia studies (4 weeks and 12 weeks) found no change in gut bacteria. Aspartame and sucralose raised inflammation markers in animal studies. So far, the research is small and mixed, and the effects seem to vary from person to person.

Taste matters, too. We tried a no-sugar-added ketchup sweetened with sucralose once, and none of us could eat it, so we switched back to regular ketchup with a little added sugar.

Other Downsides of Regular and Diet Soda

The research links soda to more than inflammation.

Regular sodaDiet soda
TeethAcid wears down enamel, and the sugar feeds the bacteria that cause cavitiesAcid wears down enamel, too.
Type 2 diabetes13% higher rate per daily serving, after accounting for weight8% higher, but a less reliable result.
MoodPeople who drank the most sugary drinks had about a 31% higher risk of depressionSimilar, about 31% at four or more cans a day in older adults
BonesDaily cola was linked with 4 to 5% lower hip bone density in older womenDiet cola was linked, too. Non-cola sodas, like lemon-lime, weren’t.
Heart and lifespanTwo or more a day was linked with a 21% higher death rate, mostly from heart disease.Linked only at two or more a day, only in women, and needs more research to back this up.
Liver fatAbout three cans a day for six months more than doubled liver fat.The same amount of diet cola didn’t raise liver fat. It did no worse than water.
GutAbout three cans’ worth of sugar at once raised bacterial toxin in the blood by about 45%.Sweeteners changed gut bacteria in some people.

Everything in this table except the teeth, liver fat, and gut rows comes from studies that follow people over time, so it shows links, not cause. Mood can change what people drink, too. 

For my occasional migraine Dr Pepper, I still choose regular. It’s one mini can every month or two, and for me the sugar is part of what helps. For an everyday drink, the evidence so far favors diet over regular, though the newest Dietary Guidelines recommend limiting both.

Water, sparkling water, or unsweetened tea is the swap with the fewest question marks. I share what I drink in my anti-inflammatory drinks article, and if you’re in midlife and thinking about your bones, my osteoporosis diet guide covers what helps.

How Much Sugar Is Okay?

Most of us eat well past the recommended limits.

Added sugar a day
American Heart Association limit, most womenAbout six teaspoons (25 g)
American Heart Association limit, most menAbout nine teaspoons (36 g)
Dietary Guidelines, 2025–2030None is considered part of a healthy diet. If you have some, no more than 10 g (about 2½ teaspoons) per meal.
What US adults average17 teaspoons (68 g)
One 12-ounce regular soda10 teaspoons (40 g)
Share of US adults’ added sugar from sugary drinks plus sweetened coffee and teaMore than 40% (2020 Dietary Guidelines)

To read a label, look for “Added sugars” under Total Carbohydrate. Every 4 grams is about one teaspoon. One regular soda puts most women well past the daily limit before they eat anything.

Added sugar shows up in places you might not expect. Here are a few swaps I make.

Instead of…Added sugarI choose…Added sugar
Yoplait Original Strawberry yogurt (6 oz)13 gChobani Less Sugar Greek yogurt (5.3 oz), or plain Fage 2% Greek yogurt with fruit5 g, or 0 g
Flavored instant oatmeal packet (apple cinnamon)8 gQuaker Lower Sugar instant packet (occasionally), or plain oats with fruit, as I explain in Is Oatmeal Anti-Inflammatory?2 g, or 0 g
Prego Traditional pasta sauce (½ cup)4 gRao’s Homemade Marinara0 g
Starbucks Grande Blonde Vanilla Latte (16 oz)About 17 gThe same drink half-sweet, or coffee with a splash of half-and-halfAbout 8 g, or 0 g

Starbucks lists total sugar, not added sugar. A plain Grande Caffè Latte has 18 grams of sugar, all from the milk. The vanilla latte has 35 g, so about 17 g comes from the syrup.

For pizza night, I make my own pizza sauce with tomato paste, water, and spices, so there’s no added sugar at all. It’s easy to keep in the pantry, too!

How to Cut Back Without Giving Up Dessert

Since drinks are where added sugar adds up fastest, that’s where I start.

  • Drinks. Most drinks in our house have no added sugar. For the adults, it’s water, sparkling water, and morning coffee with a splash of half-and-half. My boys drink water and unsweetened Ripple or almond milk, split one can of Poppi or sparkling water three ways, and have IZZE once or twice a year. All 13 drinks I make and buy are in my anti-inflammatory drinks article.
  • Homemade dessert. About once a month, my boys and I bake together: dark chocolate chip cookies or pumpkin bread with whole wheat flour, pumpkin pie at the holidays, and homemade birthday cakes. They learn to read a recipe, measure, and bake, and we make memories doing it.
  • Less sugar, same recipe. I use a quarter to a third less sugar than a recipe calls for. If it calls for 1 cup, use about ⅔ to ¾ cup.
  • Everyday sweets. Energy bites satisfy their (and my) sweet tooth, and so does fruit, on oatmeal or in their favorite chocolate banana and tropical smoothies. Around Halloween, it’s a mini piece of candy with a meal, or a small square of 70% dark chocolate.
  • Sweets with meals. I serve dessert with dinner, not as a reward afterward, so nobody has to clean their plate to earn it. Eating sugar with protein and vegetables is also easier on blood sugar.

A slice of pie on Thanksgiving isn’t the problem. Remember, it’s about the pattern, not perfection.

FAQ

How Long Does Inflammation From Sugar Last?

In a lab study where blood sugar was held elevated at about 270 mg/dL by IV for five hours, inflammation markers rose within two hours and returned to normal within three hours in people without diabetes. In people with prediabetes, the rise lasted about four hours. For comparison, the highest reading I caught after a bowl of oatmeal was 113 mg/dL.

Can High Blood Sugar Cause Inflammation?

Yes. In the same lab study, people with prediabetes started with higher inflammation markers than people with normal blood sugar. Blood sugar that stays high over months and years is also linked with more infections in people with diabetes. That’s one reason steady blood sugar matters, especially with insulin resistance.

Is Sugar an Inflammatory Food?

Not in small amounts. However, a daily habit of excess added sugar, especially sugary drinks, is linked over years with weight gain, fatty liver, and type 2 diabetes, which all involve inflammation. Whole fruit is different: in feeding studies, fruit lowered inflammation markers.

Takeaways

  • Add fruit. Whole fruit lowered inflammation markers, so keep it on the plate.
  • Start with drinks. Sugary drinks are the biggest source of added sugar and have the clearest links to weight gain, fatty liver, and type 2 diabetes.
  • Think habits, not single treats. A daily sugar habit over years matters more than one dessert.
  • “Natural” still counts. Honey and maple syrup act like table sugar.
  • Treat six teaspoons as a limit, not a goal. Dessert can still fit.

For a full list of what to eat more of and what to limit, grab my free printable anti-inflammatory food lists.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top